Spice Substitute Finder
Out of cinnamon, cumin, paprika or nutmeg? Pick the spice you are missing and get the closest substitute, the ratio, and what changes in flavour.
Out of cinnamon? Use nutmeg or allspice
1 tsp — of Nutmeg or allspice
Replace 1 tsp of cinnamon with 1 tsp of nutmeg or allspice.
Use the same amount. Nutmeg is warmer and stronger — start with 3/4 as much and taste. Allspice tastes like cinnamon, nutmeg and clove together.
Freshness beats the original: ground spices lose flavour in months. A substitute from a fresh jar often tastes better than the original from a three-year-old jar. Taste and adjust.
Formula used: Most spice substitutes swap 1:1 by volume. Stronger substitutes (nutmeg, turmeric, cayenne) use less; milder ones use the same amount.
How the spice substitute finder works
Pick the spice you are out of and the tool gives the closest substitute, the ratio and what changes. Cinnamon swaps for nutmeg or allspice; cumin for ground coriander; paprika for ancho chilli powder; nutmeg for mace. The ratios are usually 1:1, with notes where a substitute is stronger or milder.
Watch out for
A substitute is close, not identical. Allspice is not a mix of spices — it is one spice that tastes like cinnamon, nutmeg and clove together. Ground spices lose their flavour in months, not years, so a substitute from a fresh jar often beats the original from a three-year-old jar. Taste and adjust.
Try next: Butter to Oil Converter · Yeast Converter · Fresh to Dried Herb Converter
← All 32 tools · Cups to Grams guides · Substitutions · Recipe scaling