You can use natural cocoa instead of Dutch-processed cocoa at a ratio of 1:1 — but you must swap the baking powder for baking soda. That is the reverse of the Dutch-for-natural swap, and the chemistry is the mirror image: Dutch cocoa is neutral, so it needs baking powder, while natural cocoa is acidic, so it needs baking soda. The flavour also changes in reverse: natural cocoa is sharper, fruitier and more bitter than Dutch cocoa, with a lighter, reddish-brown colour. This is the swap for the baker with natural cocoa in the cupboard and a recipe that calls for Dutch cocoa, and it works well — as long as you fix the leavening, and as long as you are happy with a lighter, sharper cake.

The ratio, in a table

The ratio is 1:1 (swap baking powder for baking soda). Chocolate swaps by weight, not volume; cocoa powder needs added fat to replace solid chocolate. The table below converts the amounts you are most likely to meet.

Dutch-processed cocoa called for Natural cocoa to use Notes
1 tablespoon 1 tablespoon
1/4 cup 1/4 cup
1/3 cup 1/3 cup
1/2 cup 1/2 cup
2/3 cup 2/3 cup
3/4 cup 3/4 cup
1 cup 1 cup
1 1/2 cups 1 1/2 cups
2 cups 2 cups

No cup weights are published in our ingredient data for these two ingredients, so this swap is measured by volume — or by weight, where the ratio is given by weight. Do not guess a weight for either ingredient. All cup weights are approximate — densities vary by brand, by how the ingredient is packed, and by moisture — so verify with a kitchen scale where weighing matters, especially in baking.

Worked examples

A chocolate cake that is lighter and sharper

A chocolate cake calls for 3/4 cup of Dutch-processed cocoa and 1 teaspoon of baking powder. Replace the cocoa with 3/4 cup of natural cocoa, and replace the baking powder with 1 teaspoon of baking soda. The cake will be lighter in colour — a reddish-brown rather than a deep, dark brown — and sharper and fruitier in flavour than the Dutch cocoa version. The crumb will be slightly lighter and more open, because the baking soda reacts with the cocoa's acidity to give a different lift. Bake at the same temperature and time. The result is a cake that tastes more old-fashioned and more chocolatey in a sharp, fruity way — which many people prefer.

Brownies that are fruitier and less mellow

A brownie recipe asks for 1/2 cup of Dutch-processed cocoa and 1/2 teaspoon of baking powder. Use 1/2 cup of natural cocoa instead, and replace the baking powder with 1/2 teaspoon of baking soda. The brownies will be lighter in colour and sharper in flavour than the Dutch cocoa version, with a fruity, slightly bitter chocolate taste. The texture will be slightly lighter and less dense. Bake as usual. The result is a brownie that tastes more like a classic American brownie — sharp, chocolatey and a little bitter — rather than a dark, mellow European-style brownie.

A chocolate frosting that is lighter and sharper

A chocolate frosting recipe calls for 1/2 cup of Dutch-processed cocoa, beaten with butter and icing sugar. Replace it with 1/2 cup of natural cocoa, and make the frosting exactly as usual — no leavening adjustment is needed, because a frosting has no baking powder or baking soda. The frosting will be lighter in colour and sharper in flavour than the Dutch cocoa version, with a fruity, slightly bitter chocolate taste. The result is a frosting that looks and tastes like a classic American chocolate frosting. This is the easiest use of the swap, because there is no leavening to fix.

What changes in the result

Two things change when you use natural cocoa instead of Dutch-processed cocoa, and both matter. First, the acidity: natural cocoa is acidic, while Dutch cocoa is neutral, so the leavening must change — natural cocoa needs baking soda, Dutch cocoa needs baking powder. If you forget this, the cake will not rise properly: baking powder with an acidic cocoa can give too much lift and a coarse crumb, or the cake can taste metallic. Second, the flavour: natural cocoa is sharper, fruitier and more bitter, with a lighter, reddish-brown colour, while Dutch cocoa is darker, smoother and more mellow. In a cake or a brownie, the swap gives you a lighter, sharper result. In a frosting, where there is no leavening, the swap is simply a flavour and colour change — lighter, sharper, fruitier.

When not to substitute

Do not use chocolate chips where the recipe needs melted chocolate — the stabilisers stop them melting smoothly. Do not use natural cocoa instead of Dutch-processed cocoa without swapping the baking powder for baking soda — the cake will not rise properly, and it may taste metallic or have a coarse crumb. Do not use it in a recipe that needs Dutch cocoa's dark colour, such as a black-and-white cookie or a dark chocolate cake, because natural cocoa will give you a lighter, reddish-brown colour. Do not use it in a recipe that needs Dutch cocoa's mellow flavour, such as a delicate chocolate mousse, because natural cocoa's sharpness will dominate. And do not assume the two cocoas are interchangeable in every recipe: they are interchangeable by volume, but not by chemistry.

Practical guidance

Use the same amount by volume, and swap the leavening: replace baking powder with baking soda, in the same amount, when you switch from Dutch cocoa to natural cocoa. If the recipe has no other acidic ingredient, the baking soda will react with the cocoa's acidity — that is the point. Sift the cocoa powder before measuring it, because it clumps — a cup of cocoa powder weighs about 84 grams, so verify with a kitchen scale where weighing matters. In a frosting or a sauce, where there is no leavening, the swap needs no adjustment at all. All amounts here are approximate, and the 1:1 ratio is by volume.

Frequently asked questions

How much natural cocoa do I use instead of Dutch-processed cocoa?

Use the same amount: 1 cup of natural cocoa for 1 cup of Dutch-processed cocoa. But swap the leavening — natural cocoa needs baking soda, while Dutch cocoa needs baking powder.

Why do I need to swap baking powder for baking soda?

Natural cocoa is acidic, so it reacts with baking soda to give lift. Dutch cocoa is neutral, so it needs baking powder. If you use baking powder with natural cocoa, the cake can rise too much and taste metallic.

Does natural cocoa taste the same as Dutch-processed cocoa?

No. Natural cocoa is sharper, fruitier and more bitter, with a lighter, reddish-brown colour. Dutch cocoa is darker, smoother and more mellow. The difference is noticeable in a cake.

Can I use natural cocoa in a recipe that needs a dark colour?

Not if the dark colour matters. Natural cocoa gives a lighter, reddish-brown colour, while Dutch cocoa gives a deep, dark colour. For a black-and-white cookie or a dark chocolate cake, keep the Dutch cocoa.

Can I use natural cocoa in frosting?

Yes, and it is the easiest use of the swap. A frosting has no leavening, so no adjustment is needed. The frosting will be lighter in colour and sharper in flavour than the Dutch cocoa version.

Related links